How to Qualify for Real Estate Professional Tax Status

Have you ever heard of a high-income professional who pays little to no taxes? A big part of this could be the Real Estate Professional Status (REPS). This special tax status allows you to deduct depreciation (passive) losses from real estate properties against your W2 income (even as a doctor or dentist).

REPS status comes with specific requirements and is only beneficial under certain conditions. If you’re thinking about getting into real estate mainly for these tax benefits, it’s crucial to understand all that’s involved.

Before you start investing in long-term rental properties, talking to an accountant who understands REPS will help ensure you’re prepared to meet all the necessary IRS criteria.

If you want to work with the one I use, click HERE for a free strategy call. 

This article will explain how REPS works, who can benefit from it, and what you need to know to use it effectively in your tax strategy. 

If you’re more of a visual learner, check out this video instead:

---

---

What is Real Estate Professional Status (REPS)?

High-income earners are constantly looking for effective tax strategies, especially those with limited deductions available from their main job salaries, like W2 or 1099 income.

Real estate is often touted as a tax-advantaged investment, but typically, the benefits, particularly from passive real estate investments, can only offset passive income streams. This doesn’t help those of us who are doctors or dentists unless we can qualify (or our spouse) for REPs.

Leveraging REPS to Offset Main Job Income

With Real Estate Professional Status (REPS), you gain the ability to apply the tax advantages from real estate investments to offset not just passive income but also your active income. This is possible through the magic of depreciation.

The Role of Depreciation in Tax Advantages

Depreciation allows you to reduce the recorded value of your property over time according to a set schedule, which can make a significant portion of cash flow from your real estate investments tax-advantaged.

Normally, this “paper loss” can only offset passive income from other investments. However, with REPS, you can use it to reduce your taxable income from your primary job, which is a major reason why some real estate investors pay little to no taxes.

Navigating the IRS Requirements for REPS

Achieving REPS isn’t straightforward. There are stringent requirements set by the IRS, and these are rigorously checked.

It’s critical to ensure you meet these criteria to withstand an IRS audit. Working with a knowledgeable accountant who specializes in real estate is essential to help navigate these rules and maintain accurate documentation.

Understanding Depreciation in Real Estate

What is Depreciation?

Depreciation is often referred to as a “phantom expense” because it represents the gradual loss in value of your property over time due to factors like wear and tear on the roof and floors.

The IRS allows property owners to depreciate the value of a building down to zero over a period of 27.5 years, translating to about 3.6% of the property’s purchase price each year.

Accelerated Depreciation: Enhancing Early Benefits

While standard depreciation spreads the deduction evenly across 27.5 years, accelerated depreciation offers a way to claim larger deductions sooner.

This can be achieved through a cost segregation study, which identifies parts of the property that can be depreciated over a shorter time span, thus increasing your tax deductions in the initial years of ownership.

Depreciation vs. Appreciation

If you find it hard to understand that real estate depreciates while often appreciating in value, think of it like a car. A car loses value the moment it leaves the dealership, continuing to depreciate over time.

Similarly, the IRS allows depreciation on rental properties to account for increasing maintenance costs and replacements over time, even though the property might gain value in the real estate market.

This approach acknowledges the ongoing investment required to maintain the property’s operational status.

How To Qualify for Real Estate Professional Status 

To qualify for Real Estate Professional Status (REPS), the IRS has set specific criteria that must all be met, not just one:

1. Majority of Professional Time in Real Estate:

   • You or your spouse (if filing jointly) must spend over 50% of your professional time in real estate activities compared to any other professional engagements. This ensures that real estate is the primary focus of your work. For instance, if you work a full-time job as an orthopedic surgeon for 80 hours a week, you likely won’t meet this criterion.

2. Minimum Hours Requirement:

   • You must dedicate at least 750 hours during the tax year to real property trades or businesses in which you materially participate. These activities can include property development, construction, acquisition, conversion, rental, operation, management, leasing, and brokerage.

Active Participation vs. Investor Activities

• Active Managerial Participation:

  • The IRS specifies that the hours counted towards the 750-hour requirement must involve active managerial activities. This means hands-on tasks such as finding tenants, managing renovations, and other day-to-day operations of real estate.

• Exclusions from Qualifying Hours:

  • Activities such as learning about real estate investing, researching properties, or managing real estate finances in a non-managerial capacity are generally not counted. These are categorized as investor activities rather than managerial tasks.

Clarification on Education and Research Hours

• While some argue that hours spent on education and research might count towards the 750-hour requirement, this is open to interpretation and often does not qualify if the quantity is substantial. Case law suggests that these activities, being more passive and less directly involved with property management, are typically viewed as investor-type activities.

Joint Filing Considerations

• If you’re married and filing jointly, only one spouse needs to meet the criteria for both to benefit from the REPS on your joint tax return.

This stringent set of criteria is designed to ensure that only those who are truly engaged in real estate at a professional level can claim the associated tax benefits. It’s advisable to maintain detailed records and work closely with a tax advisor to navigate these requirements effectively.

Qualifying Activities	Non-Qualifying Activities
Property development	Learning about real estate
Redevelopment	Researching real estate investment opportunities
Construction	Handling the finances in a “non-managerial capacity”
Reconstruction	Reviewing financial statements
Acquisition or conversion
Rental activity
Operation and management
Leasing and/or brokerage

Join the Passive Investors Circle

Understanding Material Participation

Material participation is the core of Real Estate Professional Status and requires rigorous documentation to meet IRS scrutiny. Exaggerating involvement in real estate activities can lead to serious consequences, making it crucial to have concrete proof of participation.

Ways to Meet Material Participation Requirements

There are seven methods to fulfill the material participation requirement (see below for more detail), with the expectation that the individual claiming REPS must engage in these activities on a regular, continuous, and substantial basis.

Detailed Review of Material Participation Criteria

Understanding the nuances of material participation is essential, as it may determine whether pursuing REPS is feasible for you. Each rental property must individually show material participation to claim tax benefits for that specific property.

Grouping Properties: A Strategy with Consequences

While grouping properties under a single activity can simplify meeting the material participation standard, it carries significant long-term tax implications.

Consultation with a CPA is vital before considering this option to ensure it aligns with your overall tax strategy.

Considerations for Married Couples Filing Jointly

For married couples filing jointly, it’s important to note that while only one spouse needs to qualify for REPS, you cannot combine hours to meet the initial qualification criteria.

However, when it comes to material participation, both spouses’ hours toward rental activities can be combined, allowing greater flexibility in meeting the requirement.

Seeking Professional Guidance

Given the complexities of REPS, engaging with a tax professional who specializes in real estate is strongly recommended. This ensures you receive accurate, tailored advice to navigate the REPS criteria effectively. Always verify current regulations and seek expert consultation to remain compliant and informed about potential changes to tax laws.

What counts as “material participation”?

Here are the criteria directly from the IRS to clarify what counts as material participation for a tax year:

1. 500-Hour Test: You participated in the activity for more than 500 hours during the tax year.

2. Substantial Participation Test: Your participation was substantially all the activity of all individuals for the year, including those who didn’t own an interest in the activity.

3. 100-Hour and As Much As Any Other Test: You participated for more than 100 hours, and no other participant (including non-owners) was involved more than you.

4. Significant Participation Activities: If the activity is a significant participation activity (more than 100 hours but you do not meet other material participation tests), and your total participation in all such activities exceeds 500 hours.

5. Five of Ten Year Test: You materially participated in the activity for any 5 of the previous 10 years.

6. Personal Service Activity: The activity was a personal service in which you participated for any three preceding tax years. This includes services in health, law, engineering, architecture, accounting, and others where capital isn’t a major income factor.

7. Facts and Circumstances Test: Based on all facts and circumstances, your participation was regular, continuous, and substantial throughout the year.

How Can Someone Like a Doctor Achieve REPS Status?

The reality for full-time physicians is that meeting the Real Estate Professional Status (REPS) requirement on their own can be extremely challenging.

To fulfill the 750-hour criterion, a doc would need to dedicate approximately 14-15 hours per week to real estate activities. These activities must involve direct, hands-on management—simply researching properties or overseeing finances online does not suffice.

However, many families with physician/dental members successfully claim REPS. Typically, these families fit into one of two scenarios:

1. The Spouse’s Involvement: Often, the dcotor’s spouse might work part-time or not at all, allowing them to dedicate the necessary time to real estate activities, thereby meeting the REPS criteria.

2. Physician Reduces Clinical Hours: Some docs may choose to reduce their medical practice hours significantly. This shift allows them to spend the majority of their professional time on real estate, thus qualifying for REPS.

IRS Red Flags for Claiming Real Estate Professional Status (REPS)

When someone claims Real Estate Professional Status (REPS), certain factors can immediately prompt scrutiny from the IRS. Here are some common red flags that could lead the IRS to challenge your claim of material participation:

Challenge	Description
Geographic Distance	If your property is far from where you reside, the IRS may question your ability to materially participate in day-to-day management.
Full-Time Employment	A full-time job requiring more than 40 hours a week may raise doubts about your capacity to meet REPS hour requirements.
Use of Property Management	Hiring a property manager to handle daily operations signals limited direct involvement, which is key for REPS qualification.
Non-Essential Activities	Claiming activities that aren’t critical to the property’s operation could indicate insufficient material participation.

Documenting for Compliance

To solidify your claim for Real Estate Professional Status (REPS) and withstand IRS scrutiny, meticulous documentation is essential. Here’s what you need to keep track of and how to ensure your documentation supports your status:

Essential Documentation Practices

1. Detailed Activity Logs: Maintain a daily or near-daily log of all your real estate activities. This should include phone calls, property visits, meetings with tenants, and time spent on repairs and management. The IRS does not accept estimates, so precise records are crucial.

2. Retain All Relevant Records: Keep all emails, receipts, credit card statements, bank statements, and cell phone records that relate to your real estate activities. These documents are vital for substantiating your involvement and material participation.

3. Document Non-Real Estate Activities: It’s also wise to log any non-real estate professional activities. This helps demonstrate that the majority of your professional time is indeed spent on real estate, which is a requirement for REPS.

Ensuring Reliable Claims

• Regular Reviews with Your Accountant: Work closely with an accountant familiar with real estate and REPS requirements. They can help ensure your logs and documentation are thorough and in compliance with IRS standards.

• Choose Your Accountant Wisely: Be cautious of accountants who claim to frequently handle REPS claims without rigorously ensuring compliance. The IRS may audit other clients of an accountant if they discover one client improperly claimed REPS. This could lead to broader audits for any clients claimed under similar circumstances.

• Burden of Proof: If audited, having detailed records shifts the burden of proof to the IRS to disprove your claims rather than relying on you to prove your involvement after the fact.

Proactive Measures

• Update and Review: Regularly update your logs and review them with your accountant to catch any potential issues early. This ongoing diligence not only prepares you for potential audits but also helps reinforce your routine of documenting everything.

• Stay Informed: Tax laws and interpretations can change. Keep abreast of any updates to the IRS guidelines regarding REPS to ensure your compliance remains current.

The Short-Term Rental Tax Loophole and REPS

While it’s not necessarily easier to claim Real Estate Professional Status (REPS) with short-term rentals, there is a unique aspect to how they are treated under tax laws that might seem like a loophole.

Short-Term Rentals and Ordinary Income

Investing in short-term rentals can provide a similar benefit to using depreciation to offset your ordinary income (like that from a physician’s salary), but it does so without requiring you to meet the stringent 750-hour rule or having real estate as your predominant activity.

This is often referred to as the short-term rental tax loophole.

IRS Rules for Short-Term Rentals

The IRS does not classify short-term rentals (properties rented out for stays averaging seven days or less, such as those listed on platforms like Airbnb and VRBO) as typical rental activities.

This classification means they follow different rules. However, you still need to meet the material participation requirements, which essentially means actively managing the properties yourself rather than using a property manager.

Leveraging Accelerated Depreciation

In this scenario, many investors take advantage of accelerated depreciation methods on these properties to maximize upfront tax benefits. This involves claiming depreciation more rapidly in the early years of property ownership, which can significantly reduce taxable income.

Transitioning Property Management

Once the initial benefits of depreciation are utilized, many owners then transition these short-term rentals either to a property management company or convert them into long-term rentals.

This change is often strategic, allowing the owner to benefit from the depreciation while subsequently reducing the day-to-day involvement, thus making the investment more passive over time.

Strategic Considerations

To make the most of this approach, it’s crucial to be actively involved in the management of your short-term rentals if you intend to claim them for REPS benefits.

Given the complexities of tax rules surrounding short-term rentals and REPS, consulting with a tax professional who understands these nuances is advisable. This ensures that you fully comply with IRS requirements while optimizing your tax benefits.

Conclusion

The IRS closely scrutinizes claims under the Real Estate Professional Status (REPS) due to the significant tax deductions it offers. This strategy is effective only if real estate is a major part of your or your spouse’s professional activities.

Real Estate Commitment

Before investing in real estate with the aim of qualifying for REPS, understand the depth of involvement required. This status demands that real estate activities dominate your professional time, not just supplement it.

Professional Advice

Consult with a tax professional experienced in real estate before proceeding. This will help ensure that your investment aligns with tax regulations and that REPS truly benefits your financial goals.

Ideal Investment Scenario

REPS should be a bonus, not the sole reason for your real estate investment. If buying property fits into your broader investment strategy, the tax advantages from REPS can significantly boost your returns, making it a worthwhile endeavor.